# SH-23: native ninth-node qualification, 2026-11-07

OPF-owned SmartArt definitions carry tables for1–12 entries. Each of the five currently qualified designs retains a ninth node and a text edit after SaveCopyAs and reopening the edited derivative. Accepted review records all five exact results: pyramid, matrix/card grid, flow, chevrons and vertical flow. Reopened geometry errors are at most0.0000876pt, unchanged against the0.1pt gate; rotation errors are zero. Sizes, texts, nine flat levels, paragraph alignment and first-line positions pass. Independent inspection of every reopened PNG found the ninth label visible, aligned and contained, with no unexpected shape/connector change. Raw attempts and byte hashes retain the sources, sealed input copies, edited saved derivatives, PNGs, worker logs, reports and exact verifier snapshots.

The original pyramid01 is deliberately preserved as a structural pass/visual fail: the new label centered despite matching geometry. Newly added nodes lacked the explicit paragraph alignment of authored data paragraphs. The shared layout now sets parTxLTRAlign/parTxRTLAlign in every text algorithm, including9–12/fallback; the verifier checks the actual paragraph and first-line position. No edit script corrects user-node formatting. [Microsoft's custom SmartArt text guidance](https://learn.microsoft.com/ja-jp/archive/msdn-magazine/2007/february/create-custom-smartart-graphics-for-use-in-the-2007-office-system) describes these algorithm parameters.

Fresh isolated-branch inputs reproduce all five native-qualified input PPTX archives byte-exactly, together with the interpreted eighth/ninth geometry, layout identities and alignment expectations. [Generator](../../../../tools/shapes/sh-23/build-witness.mjs) refuses an existing output. Its XML reader is the evidence-only SH19 reader with package resolution changed to this checkout; no evidence branch was merged. [Verifier](../../../../tools/shapes/sh-23/verify-ninth.ps1) is coordinator-only, through the existing bounded owned worker. The five accepted snapshot SHA256 values are all ad920a299877b29bfdac65d9bfc10ab2ebb439e5261195cbedbcd865ba07f6f1. Opens use sealed copies, typed string paths, read-only visible/minimized windows and Export before probing. Every COM collection is indexed. A failure latches off later Office calls; only exact owned inputs close; only an empty owned app quits. The coordinator reports no PowerPoint process left after the accepted runs. Inputs and sources are unchanged by each run.

Vetoable scope: OPF-authored lists still have the existing maximum8. Native editing tables extend to12 where the generated geometry fits, otherwise the original8-table fallback remains. Above12 retains the documented12-entry fallback; this change does not claim native qualification for arbitrary10–12 labels, a larger authored count, a script-domain expansion, or unfinished SH20–22 work. No threshold changed.

Validation: isolated core/gallery/render/PPTX builds pass; eight focused core layout/default tests and the five-design PPTX table/part test pass. The isolated generator reproduces all five native witness files byte-exactly. Full changed-branch and assembled integration CI remain with the coordinator's batched034 gate.

The Windows PowerShell5 offline verifier test also passes: full and one-case plans create no output or Office object, existing evidence is preserved, and modified input hashes are refused.
